Log in

No account? Create an account

Katya Knyazeva's scrapbook

Shanghai history and architecture

#131 Shanghai Architecture Series in Russian: Holy Trinity Cathedral 圣三一堂 (1869)
This article was written in Russian for the Shanghai Architecture Series in Magazeta: https://magazeta.com/2019/05/arc-holy-trinity-church/
English version coming up soon.

Men carrying concubines in Shanghai brothel district (c. 1905)
Brothel servants are photographed carrying girls along Baoshan Jie (宝善街), the location of many second-tier (yao'er) brothels, which corresponds to today's stretch of Guangdong Road between Henan Road and Fujian Road.

Images found on ebay by

Great photographic album from 1921
A great photographic album of A. S. Hitchcock (1921), available in hi-res on achive.org. Shanghai views begin on page 38:


#3 Russian Culture in Shanghai series (in Chinese): Women couturiers of old Shanghai
Link to the article in Chinese: http://tsrus.cn/lishi/2019/05/24/665905

Eleanora Garnett showing her creation to a client in 1946. Image: George Silk.

#2 Russian Culture in Shanghai series (in Chinese): Arcadia Cabaret on Route Doumer
Link to the article in Chinese: http://tsrus.cn/lishi/2019/05/02/665643

Burlesque dance on the summer terrace in Arcadia Cabaret, 1940. Image: A. T. Hull, Jr.

Over 2,500 historic images of Shanghai mapped on PastVu

Girl in Pudong, 1937. Image: Jonas Gunnar Andersson.

The latest 100 additions to the Mapping Old Shanghai project include:

A couple views of David House on Kiangse Road:

Some views of stores on Broadway, right behind Astor House:

The beauty of this otherwise standard shot is that it is taken in 1929 just before the scaffolding on the Sassoon House (right) came off:

Two old cinemas in one frame. Thanks go out to genius 老壶嚼早2 for finding and idetifying this, and many other photographs:

Some views of Shanghai in 1991, from Bernard Annebicque's collection on Getty:

A fabulous series of high-angle shots taken from the top of the Trinity Church, showing how developed Shanghai was back in 1850s (the photo is from the endless treasure trove of Historic Photographs of China):

Also, some views of the Trinity Church as it was until 1864 – it looks rather sturdy, which evidently, it was not:

All of the Ford Hire Services are now properly attached to their locations – thanks to 随意-sy:

Now all three of the improbable rocky views of Shanghai are on the map (1, 2, 3):

So far I've been avoiding the Broadway Mansions (too obvious a target for so many photographers), but now I finally threw a whole bunch of its images on the map. I caught some flak for this beautiful luggage tag, after some moderators doubted its artistic merit:

I'm always happy to find new photographs of the old town, and now thanks 随意-sy's help with identification, there is this series of high-angle shots of Minkuo Road 民国路 (now Renmin Road) in 1931:

Other additions can be found in the Gallery. There is now a Facebook page where I post highlights from this project: Mapping Old Shanghai.

Link to the map

You can use various base maps: Mapnik street map, Google Scheme, Google Satellite or Yandex Satellite (sometimes sharper than Google).

To switch between architectural drawings and photographs, select the icon with the landscape or the photocamera. To open each image in a new window click the icon with the arrow to the right of the landscape icon:

A boat ride along Shanghai streets in 1940

There is some severe watermarking, but it is still possible to enjoy the audacity of these lads attempting to row in a sampan along Route Cardinal Mercier, after a flooding rain in 1940. The Auto Palace is in the background.

Madame Wellington Koo on Shanghai style

Mme Wellington Koo in 1921. Image: Library of Congress.

She found Shanghai in the 1920s wanting and thought it "filled with...British shipping people...nobodies at home...[who] put on upper-class airs in China...They were so insular, so middle-class...and looked down their noses at everything really beautiful and indigenous to...[Chinese] culture: jade, porcelain, antiques. And the poor foolish Shanghai Chinese were so impressed with these upstarts that they copied their manners and filled their houses with 'Western' furniture (the so-called smart Shanghai furniture all came from Grand Rapids and was heavy and ugly)."

Quoted in Wikipedia, from Koo & Taves, No Feast Lasts Forever (1975).

Hand-drawn aerial map of Shanghai, seen from the north

Image: North-China Sunday News, Feb 28, 1932.

This map was published in the aftermath of the "Shanghai Incident," during which the residential district of Chapei (Zhabei) was incinerated.

#130 Shanghai Architecture Series: Japanese Buddhist Temple Nishi Honganji (1931)
This article was originally written for the Russian-language architecture series in Magazeta.

Japanese Buddhist Temple Nishi Honganji
455 Zhapu Road / 乍浦路455

The history of the Japanese in Shanghai is mostly written with blood. The lengthy and violent occupation of the city in 1937–1945 has mostly replaced the memory of peaceful coexistence. But a number of Japanese landmarks still stand in the north of the downtown, where in the early 20th century tens of thousands of Japanese citizens lived. One of these landmarks is the Buddhist temple Nishi Honganji 西本愿寺上海别院, now used as the cabaret The Pearl. Japanese tourists still visit the former temple, and aside from its cult significance, this is one of the most eclectic buildings in Shanghai.

In the second half of the 19th century, modernized Japan pursued political and economic expansion into the Southeast Asia and China, and following this trend, various Japanese religions began to set up missions in China. The most active among them was Nishi Honganji, the West branch of the Buddhist School of the Pure Land, founded in Japan around the turn of the 13th century and later split into the East (Higashi 东) and West (Nishi 西) branches. Nishi Honganji established missions in Vladivostok, Taiwan and Hawaii before coming to Shanghai in 1906.

Just like American Protestant missionaries, Japanese Buddhist missionaries hoped to convert Chinese population to their religion. Besides preaching they also promoted the idea of pan-Asianism, with Japan at the top of the hierarchy. But foreign brands of Buddhism aroused no interest among the Chinese public, so Japanese missions had to switch to serving their own compatriots – granted, they were arriving by the thousands.

In the 1910s and the 1920s, the Japanese diaspora in Shanghai was growing at the rate of 5% a year. By 1927, the Japanese population of Shanghai exceeded 25,000 and comprised a half of all foreigners. Having settled in the north of the city, the immigrants considered this district their home. Shanghai's Little Tokyo was located around North Sichuan Road, Haining Road, Tanggu Road, Wusong Road and intersecting alleys. The Japanese residents aspired to reproduce their habitual lifestyles and did not seek integration. They did not have to: Japan’s influence was powerful not only in economic and military spheres, but also in the intellectual realm. The identities and worldviews of Shanghai modernist writers such as Lu Xun were largely forged in the cafes and bookstores of Shanghai’s Little Tokyo.

The streets of Little Tokyo were replete with Japanese-language signage. There were restaurants, tailor shops, brothels, bookstores, inns, banks, hospitals, and separate schools for boys and girls. The stores traded in Japanese imported goods and accepted yen as payment: yens were officially sent to Shanghai for the use in Little Tokyo. In anticipation of the New Year, thousands of fresh pine trees were shipped from Nagasaki, decorated and then placed outside doors of residences and businesses. People strolled about wearing kimonos and geta sandals, carrying round umbrellas. Little Tokyo even had its own symbolic mayor, elected by the Japanese Residents’ Association.

In Shanghai port around the year 1930. Image: Louis-Philippe Messelier.

[Click to continue reading...]

Postcard with a view of North Sichuan Road. Image: Boston Museum of Fine Arts.

A 1931 cartoon illustrating the relationship of the Chinese and Japanese in Shanghai. Image: Sapajou.

To mark national holidays and conduct burials there was a Shinto shrine with an expansive cemetery (its place is now occupied by Hongkou Park 虹口公园). At least three Japanese Buddhist sects had their temples in Shanghai, and one of them was Nishi Honganji. In 1931, it relocated to a new building on Zhapu Road.

The architect of the building, Okano Shigehisa (岡野重久), purposefully chose a hybrid style. The resemblance to Hindu temples was intended to highlight shared origins of Indian and Japanese schools of Buddhism. Shanghai’s Nishi Honganji temple was not the only hybrid of this kind: the mission had a similar building constructed in Dalian. The mission architects were equally inspired by the Muslim palatial architecture such as Taj Mahal and British colonial administrative buildings, known as Indo-Saracenic architecture. All of these influences, transplanted to the Shanghai soil by the hands of Japanese architects, resulted in a very eclectic building.

The outer wall of the Nishi Honganji temple has a relief lintel with ten pairs of birds; underneath them there are 21 versions of a lotus flower. A giant horseshoe arch is a reference to Moorish and Moroccan architecture, while the bowed roof line reminds of Bengali palaces. The tunnel-like side entrance and internal vault is borrowed from Hindu chaitya temples, which were often carved in a mountainside. Massive pillars on both sides of the porch are a reference to Persian buildings. There was a 30-meter memorial stupa in the back that loomed over the neighborhood (it was demolished during the Cultural Revolution).

Side view of the porch. Image: minguotupian.com.

Funeral ceremony in the Nishi Honganji temple. Image: minguotupian.com.

Ceremony in front of the temple in 1932. Image: 图画时报.

Corner of Haining Road, one block south from the Nishi Honganji temple. The memorial stupa is towering on the horizon. Image: Collection of Li Shengkai.

Population of Little Tokyo cheering their soldiers on their way to fight the Chinese in early 1932. Image: 满洲建国及上海大事变史.

Soon after the opening of the temple, in late January 1932 the Japanese army attacked the north of the city and incinerated the residential district of Chapei (Zhabei). The Nishi Honganji temple was then used for funeral services for the fallen "warriors.” The next few years were relatively peaceful, but the Japanese military presence in the area was growing, and the civilian population swelled too. The fragile peace was disrupted in August 1937, when the Japanese warplanes began to bomb Chinese districts. This was followed by the occupation of first the Chinese, and then the foreign territories. All this time the killed soldiers received their last honors in the Nishi Honganji temple, their bodies were cremated and the ashes stored in the stupa.

After the surrender of Japan in August 1945, the military occupation came to an end. The American troops disarmed and interned the enemy soldiers, while the Japanese civilians rushed to the port to leave the city. They left behind whole blocks of houses with sliding doors and tatami floors, multiple administrative buildings and several temples, two of which survive. The East branch of the Pure Land School (Higashi Honganji 东本愿寺) on the corner of Wuchang Road was demolished, but the West Branch (Nishi Honganji 西本愿寺) at 455 Zhapu Road is now used as a cabaret The Pearl, while the former Honkokuji Temple (本圀寺), at 439 Zhapu Road, is now a residence. Their present is as eclectic as was their past.

Businessmen dining with geisha girls in 1940. Image: A. T. Hull, Jr.

Selling off possessions before repatriation in 1945. Image: George Lacks.

Japanese civilians waiting for repatriation in temporary quarters in 1945. Image: George Lacks.

The arhats' faces on some of the lotuses have been gouged out.

Above images: 走跳上海建築 Wandering thru Shanghai Architecture.

The interior the former temple. Image: SmartShanghai.

Top image: 走跳上海建築 Wandering thru Shanghai Architecture.

Richard M. Jaffe, Seeking Sakyamuni: South Asia in the Formation of Modern Japanese Buddhism
Christian Henriot, Little Japan in Shanghai: An insulated community, 1875-1945
Ronald Stone Anderson, Nishi Honganji and Japanese Buddhist Nationalism, 1862-1945
Michihiro Ama, Immigrants to the Pure Land: The Modernization, Acculturation, and Globalization of Shin Buddhism, 1898-1941
Joshua A. Fogel, Articulating the Sinosphere: Sino-Japanese Relations in Space and Time
Laikwan Pang, The collective subjectivity of Chinese intellectuals and their café culture in Republican Shanghai
The China Press
The North-China Daily News

Bonus: Former Honkokuji temple 本圀寺, at 439 Zhapu Road: